Book Review: Soulful Seas Duet
Series details
What this series is about
Reverse harem contemporary paranormal duet: Sloane, who can see ghosts, finds herself drawn into a coastal town’s mysteries—and into the lives of four brothers who need her help, and her heart.
World setting
Genres
Relationship tropes
Rating & review
My review
The Soulful Seas Duet delivers exactly what the title promises: coastal town vibes, fishing boats, unexplained mysteries, ghostly encounters, and a reverse harem that starts to form in Book 1 and fully comes together in Book 2.
I was deep in a reading slump when I picked up Whisper Waves, and it absolutely hit the spot. I was craving a small-town romance with atmosphere, and this series gave me moody seaside isolation, emotional intensity, and just enough paranormal intrigue to keep things interesting.
The ghostly elements genuinely surprised me. I’m not usually drawn to ghost stories, but here they were well-integrated and enhanced the mood instead of overshadowing the characters or the romance.
Ocean Echoes didn’t land quite as strongly for me. While it does what it needs to do—closing the story and delivering a satisfying epilogue—the pacing drags in places. Toward the end, I had to consciously stop myself from skimming a few scenes.
Sloane, the FMC, is a resilient yet somewhat naïve “sad girl” type. What really worked for me was her profession: she’s a car mechanic, and it actually feels real. It’s not a quirky detail slapped on for personality points—it grounds her and adds depth to her character.
And Saylor? Easily my favorite character in the entire series.
Overall, despite its shortcomings, I do think the Soulful Seas Duet is worth reading—especially if you connect with Whisper Waves. It’s emotional, atmospheric, and ultimately delivers a complete HEA. If you don’t mind heavier themes, some cheesiness, and repetitive moments in Book 2, this duet may really work for you.
The Soulful Seas Duet delivers exactly what the title promises: coastal town vibes, fishing boats, unexplained mysteries, ghostly encounters, and a reverse harem that starts to form in Book 1 and fully comes together in Book 2.
I was deep in a reading slump when I picked up Whisper Waves, and it absolutely hit the spot. I was craving a small-town romance with atmosphere, and this series gave me moody seaside isolation, emotional intensity, and just enough paranormal intrigue to keep things interesting.
The ghostly elements genuinely surprised me. I’m not usually drawn to ghost stories, but here they were well-integrated and enhanced the mood instead of overshadowing the characters or the romance.
Ocean Echoes didn’t land quite as strongly for me. While it does what it needs to do—closing the story and delivering a satisfying epilogue—the pacing drags in places. Toward the end, I had to consciously stop myself from skimming a few scenes.
Sloane, the FMC, is a resilient yet somewhat naïve “sad girl” type. What really worked for me was her profession: she’s a car mechanic, and it actually feels real. It’s not a quirky detail slapped on for personality points—it grounds her and adds depth to her character.
And Saylor? Easily my favorite character in the entire series.
Overall, despite its shortcomings, I do think the Soulful Seas Duet is worth reading—especially if you connect with Whisper Waves. It’s emotional, atmospheric, and ultimately delivers a complete HEA. If you don’t mind heavier themes, some cheesiness, and repetitive moments in Book 2, this duet may really work for you.
If I had to critique something
I’m personally not the biggest fan of this type of reverse harem setup. It’s not that it can’t work—it’s just hard to pull off without feeling a little awkward.
Here, the group scenes didn’t quite click for me. The dynamic often felt more like the men were taking turns with Sloane rather than forming a cohesive poly family unit. That “big found family” feeling I usually love in poly romances never fully landed.
That said, if you approach it as pure fantasy, it does the job—and this aspect may work better for readers who already enjoy brother harems.
I’m personally not the biggest fan of this type of reverse harem setup. It’s not that it can’t work—it’s just hard to pull off without feeling a little awkward.
Here, the group scenes didn’t quite click for me. The dynamic often felt more like the men were taking turns with Sloane rather than forming a cohesive poly family unit. That “big found family” feeling I usually love in poly romances never fully landed.
That said, if you approach it as pure fantasy, it does the job—and this aspect may work better for readers who already enjoy brother harems.
The romance
4
Reverse Harem (without MM)
Harem grows over time
Relationship tropes
Romance on the Soulful Seas Duet series
The romance unfolds unevenly—in a good way.
Sloane’s relationship with each member of her harem develops at its own pace, which I really appreciated. Some connections feel instant, while others take more time to grow, making the dynamics feel more natural.
That said, I wouldn’t call this a romance-driven duet. Most of the romantic depth centers on one particular character, while the others lean more heavily into tension and physicality. (I mean… the house does have a jacuzzi.)
The male love interests are all flawed in different ways, but there’s an undercurrent of hope in how their connections with Sloane are written. There’s genuine sweetness and emotional intimacy layered beneath the tension, and some of the buildup moments are genuinely well done.
And if you enjoy groveling—Book 2 delivers.
The romance unfolds unevenly—in a good way.
Sloane’s relationship with each member of her harem develops at its own pace, which I really appreciated. Some connections feel instant, while others take more time to grow, making the dynamics feel more natural.
That said, I wouldn’t call this a romance-driven duet. Most of the romantic depth centers on one particular character, while the others lean more heavily into tension and physicality. (I mean… the house does have a jacuzzi.)
The male love interests are all flawed in different ways, but there’s an undercurrent of hope in how their connections with Sloane are written. There’s genuine sweetness and emotional intimacy layered beneath the tension, and some of the buildup moments are genuinely well done.
And if you enjoy groveling—Book 2 delivers.
Reading order
Books I've reviewed from this series
Series similar to Soulful Seas Duet
Oh hey! I’m Becky, book hugger and the one-woman team behind RBM. I hope my reviews help you find a story you’ll love.